La Mina tribe, wearing orange buffs:
The Castaways
| Name | Age, Occupation | Voted Out in |
| Dan Barry | 52, ret?d astronaut | |
| Aras Baskauskas | 24, yoga instructor | |
| Austin Carty | 24, author | |
| Terry Deitz | 46, pilot | |
| Danielle DiLorenzo | 24, sales rep | |
| Cirie Fields | 35, nurse | |
| Misty Giles | 24, engineer | |
| Melinda Hyder | 32, singer | Episode 2 |
| Bruce Kanegai | 58, karate instructor | |
| Courtney Marit | 31, performance artist | |
| Bobby Mason | 32, attorney | |
| Ruth Marie Milliman | 48, retail director | |
| Shane Powers | 35, marketeer | |
| Tina Scheer | 45, logging promoter | Episode 1 |
| Sally Schumann | 27, social worker | |
| Nick Stanbury | 25, financier |